Light exercise after concussion may halt prolonged symptoms: study
By Sheryl Ubelacker The Canadian PressFeatures Clinical Patient Care
Getting physical exercise within a week of suffering a concussion may reduce a young person’s risk of experiencing ongoing symptoms, say researchers, whose finding runs counter to conventional guidelines calling for strict mental and physical rest following the common brain injury.
“Exercise is probably a good medicine,” said Dr. Roger Zemek of the Children’s Hospital of Eastern Ontario, who led the study of Canadian children and teens conducted at nine pediatric hospitals across the country.
Those who said they resumed light to moderate activity soon after a concussion – such as walking, swimming and stationary cycling – were found to be less likely to have such symptoms as nausea, headaches and dizziness a month later.
Exercise increases blood flow to the brain and could help speed up healing and improve cognitive function, which is often altered as the result of a concussion, researchers said.
“We also know that by getting outside and doing this, patients are taken away from that negative cycle of ‘I’m sick’ and being stuck in that sick role,” Zemek said from Ottawa. “And perhaps they’re seeing something they can do to help them improve.”
However, that doesn’t mean kids should resume activities that could lead to another concussion.
“Patients should always be removed from the field of play at the time of their injury and not be allowed to return that same day, and patients should not be allowed to go back into an activity … until they’ve been cleared by a qualified medical professional,” he said.
“So I’m not suggesting that a patient who’s had a concussion go back and play their football tournament or hockey tournament the next weekend.
“But a couple days after their injury, if they feel like they want to get outside and go for a walk, or they did the walk yesterday and want to … go a bit farther or a bit faster, as long as they’re not going to fall or get into a collision, I think it’s actually going to be good for them.”
To conduct the study, published Tuesday in the Journal of the American Medical Association, researchers surveyed almost 2,400 kids ranging in age from five up to 18 who were treated for concussion in hospital emergency departments. About 70 per cent of the brain injuries occurred while playing sports or doing other recreational activities.
Patients and their parents were asked about symptoms and physical activity at seven and 28 days after the concussion. In the early-exercise group, 29 per cent reported ongoing or worsening symptoms 28 days after their concussion, compared with 43 per cent of those who avoided physical activity.
Among children and teens who reported having three or more symptoms that first week, those who engaged in early physical activity were 25 per cent less likely to have ongoing or worsening problems at one month – “regardless of the intensity” – compared to those who chose rest over exercise, Zemek said.
He believes the findings suggest guidelines mandating strict rest until concussion symptoms disappear need to be reconsidered – with one caveat.
“I do feel we need to be prudent and really make sure this is not taken as a free pass to go back to competition … (not) until they’re medically cleared.”
Dr. Paul Echlin, a Burlington, Ont., sports medicine physician who treats young athletes with brain trauma, said getting a patient active at a low level without exacerbating their injury makes sense.
Echlin, who was not involved in the research, said he encourages his concussion patients to be as active as symptoms allow, asking them: ‘Can you go for a five-minute walk? Can you go and do some stretching? Can you go to the store for half an hour?’
“If you don’t isolate or don’t immobilize somebody, then you’re going to have a better result.”
While the premise of this study is reasonable, it doesn’t show how complex concussions can be, he said.
“Rest and activity are both important in the essential recovery of a person with traumatic brain injury, but so are the diagnosis of all the other components – and not to centre it around just one or the other, but to say (physical activity) is one of the many things that will help a person recover.”
An accompanying editorial says the concussion guidelines were developed due to concerns about the risk of “second-impact syndrome” if athletes resumed play while still symptomatic, along with worries that athletes might be tempted to play injured if allowed to return to play too soon.
“However, the necessity of waiting until an athlete is completely asymptomatic has resulted in some athletes resting for weeks or months, at which point rest may be less helpful and perhaps even harmful,” write Dr. Sara Chrisman of the Seattle Children’s Research Institute and Dr. Frederick Rivara of the University of Washington.
More research is needed to determine the potential benefits and harms related to early physical activity post-concussion, they say.
“Until then, clinicians and parents should use common sense about allowing limited physical activity as tolerated and be cautious about resting a previously active athlete for prolonged periods.”
Print this page